Postby Mike Cartier » Tue Oct 07, 2003 9:09 am
Actually the UFC rules clearly favor the ground and pound athletic wrestler types. Although some of the stuff prohibited would also help them alot (like headbutting on ground).
If you look at pride rules they tend to be better for the BJJ types.
eye gouging, fishhooking, throat ripping, ear eating, nostril splitting and all that other good stuff is not the fight finisher it alwasy appears to be.
For starters people are alot touhger than we want to admit sometimes, paoin is not always the deterrent it should be.
All these dirty tactics are as easily employed by a grappler, in fact for the close quarter dirty tactics the grappler is at a distinct advantage with dirty tactics.
i hear the what about if i bite you stuff all the time, well if i am on your back putting on the rear naked choke and you bite me.
not only will it not get me off you back you will have seriously upped the stakes in a combat situation with someone in a position to literally snuff your existence out.
There is a time to fight and a time to negotiate, when someone is on your back sinking in a artery choke you either know how to gain leverage to escape or you flail around in futility until you pass out or tap.
the true measure of mixed martial arts fighting is the vale tudo rules. Rounds are an arttificial construct that deviates from what happens in reality. No rounds in a fight favors the ground fighter, it can allow them to tear down your defense as you tire from constantly attacking them. Wrestlers often do this when fighting BJJ guys, then when the wrestler spends himself he gets sloppy in his submission defenses.
I think the main reason they take out throat claws and eye attacks is not becasue they would be killing each other with them in the UFC but that it looks particularly nasty and brutal when 2 guys are tearing at each others faces like wild animals and these attacks tend to leave permanent maiming injuries. remember though that permanent maiming injuries do not always stop people, just look at some police arrest reports for proof of that.
Thats not to say that submissions are the ultimate aspect of fighting, there is no ultimate maxcim to unarmed fighting now, lack of knowledge in any of the fighting ranges or types (groundfighting, kicking, boxing, knees and elbows, wrestling) is a weakness that can and will be exploited by those with the knowledge.
If you can't grapple and only strike, a grappler can negate your strikes with grappling. if you only grapple and don't strike you will end up eating strikes if your opponent has some grappling skill and negates your takedowns. if you only groundfight a wrestler will throw you on your back and pound your face in pankration style.
A good striker can keep you in his preferred striking range only some knowledge of strikeing yourself will you be able to frustrate his attempts to control the fight.
Royce gracie was able to use BJJ to control the fights using the ground fight becasue most people poo pooed its usefullness.
Now people know better and its not so easy to put someone in your guard and let them make a mistake that will give you a submission. its a different mixed martial art fight world now, nothing pure is good enough, no fighters at top level only train in one aspect of fighting.
The best fighters have no holes in thier fight plan, no weaknesses that can be exploited.
Dirt tactics are all well and good but if you use them because you are already at a strength or skill disadvantage it may do you more harm than good. There is not much point to working up your attacker into a blood frenzy by eating his ear and tearing at his throat, becasue what if that doesn;t help, you will wake up on a curb with your teeth kicked out or your arms broken.
Street combat does n ot always go to the dirtiest fighter, but to the most experienced or most athletic fighter.
If you are 150 pounds and you fighting a 250 pound wrestler or boxer skill and nothing else is your salvation, and you will need a pound of skill for every pound he outweighs you. Fighting dirty will only help if you happen to take out his eyes completely. or rip out his jugular, but then what? how do you explain to the police that you killd this guy becasue you didn't want to get your ass beat by a bigger guy.
There are so many variables to combat you can't say that dirty tactics will win fights they only add another dimension to combat, much like picking up a knife or a stick.
But then when you do that you take things up a notch be sure you are ready top lose the fight on that new level if you are already losing it in another way.