No argument at all on that point. I agree that ultimately you want a better training tool. I'm saving up for an Ensifer, or possibly a Fechterspiel for example. But for now, my Tinker does what I need it to do, and my waster works against my pell.
I definitely understand the argument for quality, but as something of an advocate for beginners and their place in the art, I try to point out alternatives where "good"w ill do.
Similar to your analogies, you don't hand a formula 1 race car to a beginning driver. They can't use it properly, and they don't need it to learn.
