Postby George Turner » Thu Nov 14, 2002 3:07 pm
I agree! Free play doesn't cost anything, and is critical to understanding swordplay. It teaches you the relative speeds and distances and how they relate. Without it, modern students would be like aspiring tennis players who've never played, nor even watched a real match. They can drill all they want, and achieve perfect form for a serve or volley, but won't have any clue as to how to play tennis. They'll have a mental image that "I hit the ball over their, and they hit it back. Then I see where they hit it, and run over to it and hit back again." Of course, they might think the goal is to hit it back and forth all day. That concept might work for children's badminton, but not tennis.
Modern students have generally only seen the movie forms, and need to spar a bit to get a basic feel for what goes on. They need to see just how "uncooperative" an opponent can be, and how some "techniques" just don't work.
It comes down to learning the difference between trying to kill someone with a sword, versus trying to execute moves to look like a hollywood swordsman. Without this testing of skills and techniques in free play, instead of mastering a martial art, you're just advancing in a pecking order based on skill at criticizing other peoples "form", while still having no idea how a fight works. I suppose that this eventually leads to someone using a rapier to perform the "spinning whirlygig of death!" as seen in the Three Musketeers.
Anyway, if you haven't done some free-play with someone who's not been taught to "respond correctly to make it look good", it's a real eye-opener, and why not open the student's eyes early so they don't spend a year thinking they're taking a medieval dance class.
Best Regards, and spar whenever the opportunity arises.
George Turner
ARMA in KY