Postby Roger Soucy » Fri Nov 19, 2004 9:58 am
I own several swords that I keep in their scabbards. I also own steel that I keep bare. My observations are this:
Steel is just as likely to rust in the open air (especially in humid locations) as it is in the scabbard.
What really matters is not using fresh or untreated leather for the scabbard, keeping a coating of something on the blade, and storing the weapon in a relatively dry area.
From what I understand the reason scabbards are supposed to rust a weapon, other than trapping moisture, is that leather is supposed to contain moisture of its own that can rust a weapon. However, treated leather, as well as treated wood, can be used without fear of rusting the sword it contains.
As always mileage will vary, but I always keep my swords in their scabbards (leather, dyed vegitable tan, thin coating of oil from sliding coated swords in) and the blades do not rust so long as I recoat them every 6 months or so (or after any use).
Recently a member of my study group turned me on to Nevr-Dull.. comes in a can, isn't messy, and protects as well as removes light oxidation/rust.