Postby Gene Tausk » Fri Mar 17, 2006 10:01 am
John had already closed this post, but just a few comments before we close it again.
I should have immediately realized that such a topic will always go off into woo-woo land and has no place on this forum. I thought, wrongly, that we could keep the discussion towards a narrow goal, but, as stated, with such a useless topic heading, this seldom occurs.
First, Joseph, as John has already said, don't ever come this forum and insult James Randi. Mr. Randi has the utmost respect from John and me as well as many other ARMA members. He has a standing challenge of $1 million for anyone who can demonstrate psychic or unusual powers. The format of the test is easy: the applicant says what he can do and then just does it (wow, if only the bar exam I took to get licensed as an attorney was so simple). Half the applicants can't even describe what "mystical" power they have, muich less describe what amazing feats they can perform. Of the other half, approximately thirty percent find some convenient excuse not to take the test and the remaining twenty percent have never even passed the preliminary exam. The James Randi Educational Foundation is a force of reason and sanity in a world which often times chooses to live in fantasyland.
Second, Franz Mesmer was indeed a crank, a quack, and any other sort of pejorative you choose to call him. Have you read about his "therapies" where he would go around dressed in a robe embroidered with moons and stars with a wand, pointing the wand at people to "cure" them of their "ailments?" Even by 18th century medical standards, this was a joke. A commission from the French Academy of Sciences, with input from our own Benjamin Franklin, labeled Mesmer's theories as pure bunk, which they were and are. If you believe in this nonsense, great. I have a bridge in Brooklyn with your name on it, for sale, cheap.
I would respectfully suggest you take some time to explore websites such as James Randi's and the Skeptic's Dictionary. You might also want to check out Penn and Teller's excellent show "Bulls**t!!"
As for "chi," as John stated, there is no evidence that this phenomena exists except as perhaps a description of the correct alignment of the human body when performing a technique. Nothing mystical in that.
The ARMA forums have enough to do with discussions of the works of the fechtmeisters, a process of discovery that can take several lifetimes. We do not have the time or interest to explore nonsense. If you want to talk about this nonsense, go to the websites that sponsor this garbage or to a children's site such as Sesame Street where it belongs.
The adults here have work to do.
No further discussions on this junk will be tolerated. Anyone attempting to post on this again will be banned from our site, which should have been done by me in the first place.
----------------->>>>>>>>>>>gene tausk
SFS
Study Group Leader - Houston ARMA Southside
Forum Monitor
------------->>>>>>>>>>>>>gene tausk
Free-Scholar
Study Group Leader - Houston ARMA Southside
ARMA Forum Moderator