Moderators: Webmaster, Stacy Clifford
Benjamin Smith wrote:So Cold Steel is scheduled to come out with a set of plastic wasters for European swords sometime this month. I doubt they've worked with anybody competent anywhere in designing it.
To be honest it looks like a black fence post. There seems to be no sign of tapering for balance and the fuller is almost certainly just for show. They would have done better replicating a Type XVa design (such as this: http://www.albion-swords.com/swords/albion/nextgen/sword-medieval-mercenary-xva.htm), at least that would have had the taper built in. Considering my exposure to their sword making, which seems to stress durability, rather than dynamic performance, or historical accuracy, I don't have high expectations for it.
There is one attractive thing about these that may persuade me to try one. It is half the price of the good wasters on the market, and being plastic probably won't ever break. It might be worth a shot.
Their training dagger on the other hand has much more appeal, as dagger simulators need much less in the performance department to work well.
Have a look: http://www.coldsteel.com/bokkens.html and tell me what you think.
Antonio Delgado wrote:Anyone else watch the video on the linked page? It's got them cutting all sorts of things with their wasters. I think these things may have more of an edge than desired for contact pratice.
Jason Taylor wrote:Also, I imagine a little work could fix balance problems (though not tapering ones) by adding a bit of weight to the handle.
Jonathan Newhall wrote:Might be a tad short, but otherwise look like great entry level wasters to me.
CalebSlagle wrote:[...]
Related to your discussion, I really don't see why there is not a 50$ option for a beginner long sword student. [...].
Dave Rogers wrote:CalebSlagle wrote:[...]
Related to your discussion, I really don't see why there is not a 50$ option for a beginner long sword student. [...].
I was just visiting the Cold Steel site and noticed that they have pushed out the date that they'll have these until 3/31/09. If it goes like some other products I've gotten there, I wouldn't be surprised if it isn't pushed out again after that. They seem to have some supply/delivery problems from time to time.
Return to “Research and Training Discussion”
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 20 guests
|
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
|||