Postby philippewillaume » Tue May 11, 2004 4:48 am
Hello karen.
From what you say I do not believe that your footwork is the cause of your trouble.
I do not think that footwork exist on its own per se. It is part of a global tactical application.
Whatever your philosophy is and if you either follow a multy master or single manual approach. You can see that there is a distinct possibility that good foot work for Ringeck may be different that the one of silver Vadi or Fiore.
Of course what each of the master says is true and the concepts can be generally applied however each master has particular applications.
If we are using a longsword and fencing according to ringeck for an example especially the "that masterhaw breaks that position/guard".
It is quite clear that footwork will never break the distance on it's own.
That is what masterhaw are for, so is it the footwork that allows the masterhaw or the master haw that allows the footwork?
You could get around it by saying that a proper footwork is the one that enable you body to deliver the strike and not the one that breaks the distance. However in my opinion it is rephrasing the question.
What I am trying to get at is that i do not think footwork can be dissociated with what you are doing.
So if you have to take short steps to strike and remain in balance , that is the way it has to be. You cannot change your body, in that respect anyway, the one you have will have to do.
(If it can be any heart lifting, Dobringer said that it is better to do two small steps than one).
In my opinion, you just need to get closer before you strike or you need to make your opponent to cover the distance for you. ( I know it sounds lame but well)
How to do it will depend of what master you follow (or what manual you want to apply if you are so inclined)
For example and not exaustively, using Sigmund
You can either step in (to shorten the distance) using sprechfenster or the lang ort or simply moving forward, if he strikes before you can either use absetzen or masterhaw to set him aside and kill him the process.(or at least gain the Vor)
Do not put yourself down, breaking the distance is very difficult to execute especially with weapons that can cut and trust,
Basically everyone has been, is or is going to go through that.
This is what pushed me to devote all my energies to a single manual. I was not able to figure it out on my own so I asked uncle Sigmund.;
I hope that helped a bit
philippe "Ringeck is the daddy" willaume
PS
i do not have a problem with mixing and matching manuals, it is not the approach I have chosen but it is fine by me as a method of research. However that is why I can not really use anything else than Ringeck as example.
One Ringeck to bring them all In the Land of Windsor where phlip phlop live.